Board footer

0.1289 sec
  • Not logged in

Views: 78
This thread has been viewed by: 22 unique users.



2008-11-29 13:11:01 (5 weeks 6 days 4 hours 22 minutes 48 seconds) #1937533 | | view posts since this          #1 

MikeinPalmSprings
Leech
Registered: 2008-11-27
Reads: 15
Posts: 3
Last seen: 40.22 days ago
Thanks given: 0
Thanks received: 0
Member #8995
Modifications : 0

Stock Rotors defective?

I read the post about problems with premature brake wear. I have the same problem on my 2006 Spec V. The front rotors were resurfaced at 8,000 miles and now at 24,000 are ready for new rotors.


Do you know the cause in general as it seems to be a design flaw on all these cars. Maybe rotors are too small for the Brembo brakes causing overheating and premature rotor wear?  Has anyone diagnosed and determined the problem yet?

As to lemon laws: premature brake wear that is not solved after reasonable attempts made during the warranty period at the dealer would fall under the lemon laws even though brakes are wear items that are replaced as maintenance. The difference is that PREMATURE WEAR is a lemon law issue. But at the dealer they usually say brake wear i not covered, you have to see a lemon aw lawyer and go thru the MANUFACTURER (basically arguing the a problem with design or manufacture by Nissan North America, the dealer is just the retail sales level and an independent dealer).     There are presumptions that the car is a lemon based on the problems and number of attempts to correct it w/o success. Resurfacing rotors doesn't SOLVE the cause of the PREMATURE WEAR, as they just wear again. Anyway, you shouldn't accept a resurface jobon a car under warranty; a resurface is not an ideal repair and even weakens the rotors ability to absorb heat which will likely accelarate the premature wear even more!

ANY COMMENTS PLEASE????

I am at this time consulting with lemon lawyers

Offline

 

2008-11-29 13:14:31 (5 weeks 6 days 4 hours 19 minutes 18 seconds) #1937536 | | view posts since this          #2 

saint0421

Batman

WTF Mate?
From: P-cola, FL
Registered: 2006-10-18
Reads: 21698
Posts: 3557
Thanks given: 10
Thanks received: 12
Vehicle: '05 SE-R Spec V
Member #311
Modifications : 2
Showoff page


Re: Stock Rotors defective?

I put 54k on my stock rotors w/ brembos. I dont recall a wide spread issue with the B15 brakes. The +07 brakes is another story.


http://i86.photobucket.com/albums/k100/saint0421/Batman2.gifhttp://i86.photobucket.com/albums/k100/saint0421/Batman2.gifhttp://i86.photobucket.com/albums/k100/saint0421/Batman2.gifhttp://i86.photobucket.com/albums/k100/saint0421/Batman2.gifhttp://i86.photobucket.com/albums/k100/saint0421/Batman2.gifhttp://i86.photobucket.com/albums/k100/saint0421/Batman2.gif

Offline

 

2008-11-29 13:15:41 (5 weeks 6 days 4 hours 18 minutes 8 seconds) #1937539 | | view posts since this          #3 

Black04SpecV
Moderator

Tony

Snowed in...
Czech Republic
From: Minnesota
Registered: 2006-04-19
Reads: 22361
Posts: 3874
Thanks given: 2
Thanks received: 25
Vehicle: '04 SE-R Spec V
Member #25
Modifications : 60
Showoff page
Website

Re: Stock Rotors defective?

Resurfacing rotors is load of bullshit. If the rotors warp, you need new rotors end of story. Resurfacing will only delay the inevitable.

I drove about 19000miles on my stock rotors. Than i upgraded to aftermarket rotors. When i took the rotors out, they were still in pretty good condition. I have non Brembo equipped SpecV.

The rotors are good size for this car, the car doesn't weigh so much, only 2800lbs...

It really depends on your driving style, conditions, etc...

The best is to upgrade to Powerslot rotors and Hawk HPS pads. That setup will last long and is suitable for track/autox use as well...


http://black04specv.myspecv.com/Tony4.png
Check out my Cardomain page! Link ---> 2004 SE-R SpecV T3/T4 powered

Online

 

2008-11-29 14:48:05 (5 weeks 6 days 2 hours 45 minutes 44 seconds) #1937584 | | view posts since this          #4 

buk_i_vdrvr

Shawn

journeyman
United States
From: cincity
Registered: 2007-11-06
Reads: 1669
Posts: 166
Thanks given: 0
Thanks received: 0
Vehicle: '04 SE-R Spec V
1/4mile: 15.288 @ 91.95
Member #2449
Modifications : 24
Showoff page

Re: Stock Rotors defective?

I am about to change my stock setup now with 50k. I will be going aftermarket next time just for cost reasons. We do seem to have a lot of brake complaints in my service dept, but the sentra usually isn't one of the problem cars. My only real complaint is they look like shit and leave rust on my wheels after I wash my car.


"Your friendly neighborhood Nissan dealer"
http://buk_i_vdrvr.myspecv.com/sig%20pic.jpghttp://buk_i_vdrvr.myspecv.com/parking%20lot-2.jpg

Offline

 

2008-11-29 15:15:27 (5 weeks 6 days 2 hours 18 minutes 22 seconds) #1937600 | | view posts since this          #5 

cute02spec
Administrator
Mama Bear
United States
Registered: 2006-06-13
Reads: 78956
Posts: 17766
Last seen: 10.49 days ago
Thanks given: 71
Thanks received: 58
Vehicle: '02 SE-R Spec V
1/4mile: 14.241 @ 102.44
Member #62
Modifications : 65
Awards : 8
Showoff page
Feedback page


Website

Re: Stock Rotors defective?

I have 46,400 on my SE-R's stock brakes... the car is driven in heavy traffic, so of course they're semi warped and worn out... I don't blame Nissan, though.  I blame the kind of traffic I have to drive in.

I put 41,000 on my Spec's stock brakes before I upgraded just because.  Those brakes weren't even worn out, I just wanted to upgrade to Powerslots because they're nice looking and I was going turbo and figured upgraded brakes were a smart idea.

Neither are Brembos.  In fact, I've rarely heard complaints from people with the Brembo brakes. 

To me, brakes are a part that wears out, and it depends on how you drive.  I don't expect brakes to last.  Lemon lawing a car 2 years after it came out because the brakes are wearing out seems silly to me honestly...


http://heidi.f3h.com/gandhsig.jpg
"The most successful people are those who are good at plan B: blow it up and build it better"
2002 SE-R Spec V - smiley-snail Snailed and Built (in progress) http://www.cardomain.com/ride/2191509 
2005 SE-R Automatic - I/H/17* timing/Raise idle   http://www.cardomain.com/ride/2753190

http://www.hmgphotos.com I take pretty pictures
http://www.spoiledbengal.com My cat > Your cat

Trav4011: Dude, I would eat the HELL out of some Heidi..

Offline

 

2008-11-29 15:39:42 (5 weeks 6 days 1 hour 54 minutes 7 seconds) #1937625 | | view posts since this          #6 

Jarek

Romeo

Sleepin At The Tree
United States
From: Hanford, ca
Registered: 2008-03-25
Reads: 3673
Posts: 391
Thanks given: 8
Thanks received: 8
Vehicle: '05 SE-R Spec V
Member #4524
Modifications : 13

Re: Stock Rotors defective?

I concur with most of you.

My brembos lasted 47k miles under lots of heavy braking, high speed stops, canyon driving, near misses etc. They were at the bleeding edge of being wasted. These are the best stock brakes I've ever had. Just imagine with a rotor upgrade.


http://c2.ac-images.myspacecdn.com/images02/30/l_c2c78ed005114d028796d5f60fda7cd5.png
It's not what you know, its who you know.
#totalchaos on Gamesurge!
http://myspace.com/rv_jd

Offline

 

Views: 78
This thread has been viewed by: 22 unique users.