Pages: 1
Topic closed

Aaron



Well here goes. I bought the treadstone kit brand new back about 8 months ago and when I first started (yes I charged the oil system first) the turbo spun for about 20 seconds and then it decided to STOP. I reved the car to 2500 for 10 min for proper turbo break-in period and never thought anything of it. So today I changed my sparkplugs and I took off the air filter+tube just to watch the turbine spin and what do you know it spins for about 10 seconds after start up and then it stops spinning. The shaft itself is pretty hard to spin by hand and if you rev really hard to say 5K rpms and let it idle again the turbine will spin for about 30 seconds or so and then it stops. I have had 3 boosted vehicles and all of them (even the journal bearing turbos) stayed spooling at idle...
I thought for sure I have a bad turbo but when running on the road it spools just fine and holds 10.5psi perfectly. What do you guys think?
Anyone with the BB tubonetics E50 turbo can you take off your air filter and see if you turbo stays spinning while at idle and also when the motor is cold is the turbine hard to spin or does it spin freely?
Remember this turbo was brand new when I bought it.
HELP!!!???
Offline

gennady gurov







thataaaat's not right... are you sure it's getting oil ?
you should pull off the oil supply line and point it in a bucket and idle the car for a bit to make sure there's oil coming through, obviously don't rev the car like this, just make sure there's oil flowing

Online

matt




Im pretty sure there was another thread that someone asked about this and the end result was that yes it will spin but very slowly. i might be wrong but thats what i remember

Online

Aaron



se-rman6 wrote:
Im pretty sure there was another thread that someone asked about this and the end result was that yes it will spin but very slowly. i might be wrong but thats what i remember
Mine stops very abrubly, does not move at all and is hard to turn by hand. O well I guess I will just wait until it does stop spooling and buy a SC61... Thanks.
But if anyone else does have this turbo can you check for me? Thanks in advance.
Last edited by 05redser (2008-09-29 23:18:11)
Offline

Aaron



gurov wrote:
thataaaat's not right... are you sure it's getting oil ?
you should pull off the oil supply line and point it in a bucket and idle the car for a bit to make sure there's oil coming through, obviously don't rev the car like this, just make sure there's oil flowing
I will try that. If there is not oil what would I have to do? Make the feed line shorter or something?
Offline

Adam




are all ur clocking bolts tight? i know when i was installing mine i was trying to get it to spin and it was tough to get it going.... well they werent tight and i thought something was wrong but the center section was pinched up against the turbine housing... just a thought:angel:

Offline

Aaron



Yea I am sure they are tight, last time my hotbolts backed out I checked all of them and made sure they were VERY tight.
Offline

Adam




i know the feeling i did the same thing when i shook a bunch of bolts.... actually just shook the only one i couldnt get out and lockwash tonight... ironic... check the compressor housing as well that will stop it from spinning if its pinched slightly too

Offline

Aaron



It has been likethis since day 1 and I have probally 5-8K on the setup. Is there a tourque # for the clocking bolts? Or just really MF tight.
I forgot to add. Once it gets to oporating (sp) temperature it still does stop at idle but not so abruptly and it is a little easier to spin the turbine shaft by hand. Any other ideas?
Last edited by 05redser (2008-09-29 23:27:36)
Offline

Adam




my bolts arent as tight as they can go(got a problem with over torquing things) just go hand tightish no limp wrist and that should be fine... they arent under as my pressure, heat, etc. as all the other hotpart bolts

Offline

Aaron



Big J wrote:
mine doesn't spin at idle
You have the journal bearing right? Have you ever heard of problems like this with the BB turbo that comes with the treadstone kit?
Offline

Aaron



Big J wrote:
do you have a journal or BB turbo? the journal comes standard
BB E50 .63A/R 50trim. Not 60Trim they were out and I got 50trim
Offline

Aaron



Big J wrote:
If it's been like that since day one and works fine, I guess it's ok.
BAH! Not the answer I wanted but thanks anyways. lol. I have never seen any turbo (even on diesels) that do not spin at idle. My friends stock mitsu eclipse gs-x turbo spins for hella long and he has over 80K on it. Journal bearing.
Last edited by 05redser (2008-09-29 23:49:10)
Offline

Jeff


something is definitely up I had the same size garret BB turbo for my first kit and it spooled hardcore at idle. And even after turning the car off it would spin for like a good 1-2 mins.
Online

Tony






My T3/T4 journal bearing spins at idle...
Online

Aaron



I definitly think something is wrong. There is very minimal shaft play up and down but there is absolutly NO shaftplay side to side. Thank you for all the responces. Any other ideas please let me know.
Offline

Adam




mine spins at idle and i just have journal bearings

Offline

Aaron



BTW my idle is raised to 982rpms which is why I am worried that something is wrong. at 800+rpms it should definitly spin.....
Offline

RJ



mine does not spin at idle.. it'll spin for a short while on start up til rpm drop then it'll spin when i tap the gas but at idle does not spin.. also spins very freely by hand. i have the BB turbo that came with the treadstone kit.
Offline

Jeff


the title of this thread should be "i have a broken turbo"
Online

Tony






Big J wrote:
Black04SpecV wrote:
My T3/T4 journal bearing spins at idle...
don't you have cams?
Yes I do have JWT cams and WRP sprocket set at +4.
Would cams make a difference?
I also have idle raised to 950rpm.
Last edited by Black04SpecV (2008-09-30 00:26:24)
Online

Josh




A 50 trim BB turbo should spin at idle. My 57 trim spins fast at idle and sins very easy by hand. It'll spin for at least a min. after I shut the car off. Your turbo is busted. If it spins hard by hnad, its fucked. Talk to treadstone, I doubt they'll do anything but maybe since its been less than a year. But you shouldve had it fixed in the 1st place when you noticed it.
Lifes to short to drive a shitty car, get in a Spec V-T
\Offline

Derek



my turbo spins when i first turn the car on but once its warmed up and falls below whatever the warm up idle speed is, it will stop spinning
i thought the same thing as you at first but it is ok and works fine
i have an sc61 journal bearing
Offline

Aaron



thanks for all the input. I think I will jsut keep running it until it completly stops and then buy a SC61 dual BB.
Offline

Jeff


SE-R Spec wrote:
my turbo spins when i first turn the car on but once its warmed up and falls below whatever the warm up idle speed is, it will stop spinning
i thought the same thing as you at first but it is ok and works fine
i have an sc61 journal bearing
yours is a bigger turbo though so....
Online

Travis a.k.a TRAV



05redser wrote:
Well here goes. I bought the treadstone kit brand new back about 8 months ago and when I first started (yes I charged the oil system first) the turbo spun for about 20 seconds and then it decided to STOP. I reved the car to 2500 for 10 min for proper turbo break-in period and never thought anything of it. So today I changed my sparkplugs and I took off the air filter+tube just to watch the turbine spin and what do you know it spins for about 10 seconds after start up and then it stops spinning. The shaft itself is pretty hard to spin by hand and if you rev really hard to say 5K rpms and let it idle again the turbine will spin for about 30 seconds or so and then it stops. I have had 3 boosted vehicles and all of them (even the journal bearing turbos) stayed spooling at idle...
I thought for sure I have a bad turbo but when running on the road it spools just fine and holds 10.5psi perfectly. What do you guys think?
Anyone with the BB tubonetics E50 turbo can you take off your air filter and see if you turbo stays spinning while at idle and also when the motor is cold is the turbine hard to spin or does it spin freely?
Remember this turbo was brand new when I bought it.
HELP!!!???
I know this response will get everyone's panties in a bunch, but whatever. I think you and eveyone else who worries about their compressor wheel not spinning at idle is a f@cking retard. If the damn thing builds 10.5psi of boost and holds it with no problem, then why are you still worrying and obsessing about it? Maybe it's just me, but I've never even bothered to look and see if my wheel spins at idle...what's the point? The car builds boost under load and runs like a scalded dog so I could give a fuck or less about what it does while the car is idling. Sorry to be a jerk(but yes, it is intentional) but this has been beat to death over the last few weeks. And if you keep reaching in there fidgetting and fooling with your compressor wheel to see why it WON'T SPIN @ IDLE!!??, that's gonna wear your bearings out faster than anything else.....end of rant.

Offline

Josh




05SpecVnBlack wrote:
05redser wrote:
Well here goes. I bought the treadstone kit brand new back about 8 months ago and when I first started (yes I charged the oil system first) the turbo spun for about 20 seconds and then it decided to STOP. I reved the car to 2500 for 10 min for proper turbo break-in period and never thought anything of it. So today I changed my sparkplugs and I took off the air filter+tube just to watch the turbine spin and what do you know it spins for about 10 seconds after start up and then it stops spinning. The shaft itself is pretty hard to spin by hand and if you rev really hard to say 5K rpms and let it idle again the turbine will spin for about 30 seconds or so and then it stops. I have had 3 boosted vehicles and all of them (even the journal bearing turbos) stayed spooling at idle...
I thought for sure I have a bad turbo but when running on the road it spools just fine and holds 10.5psi perfectly. What do you guys think?
Anyone with the BB tubonetics E50 turbo can you take off your air filter and see if you turbo stays spinning while at idle and also when the motor is cold is the turbine hard to spin or does it spin freely?
Remember this turbo was brand new when I bought it.
HELP!!!???I know this response will get everyone's panties in a bunch, but whatever. I think you and eveyone else who worries about their compressor wheel not spinning at idle is a f@cking retard. If the damn thing builds 10.5psi of boost and holds it with no problem, then why are you still worrying and obsessing about it? Maybe it's just me, but I've never even bothered to look and see if my wheel spins at idle...what's the point? The car builds boost under load and runs like a scalded dog so I could give a fuck or less about what it does while the car is idling. Sorry to be a jerk(but yes, it is intentional) but this has been beat to death over the last few weeks. And if you keep reaching in there fidgetting and fooling with your compressor wheel to see why it WON'T SPIN @ IDLE!!??, that's gonna wear your bearings out faster than anything else.....end of rant.
So your saying its ok for it to be hard to turn the wheel by hand when the cars off? NOOO.. Its junk, prob got bumped hard in shipment somewhere, something is slightly misaligned cause a slight bind.
Lifes to short to drive a shitty car, get in a Spec V-T
\Offline

Travis a.k.a TRAV



He said the turbo builds 10.5psi of boost and holds it to the redline....does that sound like a busted turbo to you?? Stop being an idiot...You've had a turbo on your car a few weeks, right? I've had one on my car for over a year and 15k miles. My dad bought our families first turbocharged car when I was like 5. I know a lil bit about the subject. If his turbo builds boost and holds it and the car is pulling healthily, there's nothing wrong with that blower. If something was misaligned, the compressor wheel WOULD HAVE PROBALY hit the walls of the compressor cover by now, and fucked his wheel up. Worryin' about why your compressor wheel doesn't spin at idle is ignorant to say the least. Worry about how the turbo operates UNDER LOOOOOOAAAAAAAD....THAT is what matters.
Last edited by 05SpecVnBlack (2008-10-02 17:42:41)

Offline

Josh




thats not all that matters. So your saying that you get a turbo and you cannot spin it by hand, that is ok? Ya, ok..keep that one to yourself, you wouldnt wanna look like an idiot. And so what if it builds and holds boost fine..sure, but he is describing something that DOES point towards something wrong with it. At idle it does not just stop spinning, he said it stops very fast, not just a fade out and stop. Sounds like you need to get a grip on what your talking about, and OMG...your dad got a turbo car when you were 5. Could you even sit in a car without a booster seat at that age let alone know it was turbo. Get a fucking grip and think about who your calling an idiot. I know just as much as you do if not more. Just because you have a turbo on for a few weeks? that makes you only know how everything works since the turbo beens on your car? sheeshh, i cant belive Im even arguing with such a selfish "know it all" pos. end rant
Lifes to short to drive a shitty car, get in a Spec V-T
\Offline

Travis a.k.a TRAV



I was trying to make a point that I had been around boosted cars for QUITE awhile...I know that they are built with different bearing clearances and such, and just because 1 type spins easily at idle that does not mean that all of them will...Look, there are ppl here saying that their turbo does and DOES NOT spin at idle....What could be wrong with a turbo that builds boost under load and holds it to redline?? PLEASE inform us. Yes, the seals could be shot, but then it would still boost fine, it would just smoke like a freight train. If the bearings were shot, he would have ALOT of shaft play and possibly a fucked up compressor wheel...has he mentioned EITHER of those problems?? If he has, I haven't read it. He's worried simply because the wheel doesn't spin the whole time the car is idling. I'd be willing to bet that I could go pull the intake pipe off my blower and my turbo doesn't spin at idle the whole time. But whatever, you know more than everyone else, including ppl that have been around this type of shit for much longer than you. I'm not a johnny-come-lately... I've been around the performance car scene since I was a little kid, and I'm fixing to be 30. OMG...I'm a fuckin' idiot.

Offline








This thread is going nowhere besides name calling now...
05redser, if you need, PM me and I can reopen the thread.
Until then, 

Snailed and Built (in progress) http://www.cardomain.com/ride/2191509 Offline