
Jeff (Not MajorMods)

From what I've read online, the Magnaflow/carsound high flow cats are of pretty good quality. I found some on ebay but had a couple questions about them.
1. Does it matter if you get a round one, or a long oval? What is the difference between the two?
2. Would I want to get one that had the o2 hole or does it not matter?
These are the links i found, any opinions/comments?
http://cgi.ebay.com/ebaymotors/MagnaFlo … enameZWDVW
http://cgi.ebay.com/ebaymotors/MagnaFlo … enameZWDVW
http://cgi.ebay.com/ebaymotors/MagnaFlo … enameZWDVW
Which is the one I would want to get?
Offline

I ran a Magnaflow Hi-Flow cat on the Maxima that I had. It was a quality piece. Other than, I don't have any information to help you out. I had the oval shape cat that resembles the stock style that the Max had at the time. You only need a Cat with an 02 hole if there's an 02 sensor on the cat. From what I hear, we don't have a sensor on out cat.
Offline

Marc

Here is the one I put on my midpipe. 2.5" oval style.
I don't think you'll need the 02 sensor bung, unless your header only has one on it. My nismo has 2 so I don't need it.
P.S. The shop showed me old and new magnaflow boxes. Old style say hi-flow, new style is exactly the same, but with a sticker over the 'hi'. Weird, but whatever. I'm lovin' it like a bad McDonalds commercial.
Offline

Blake

yeh we dont have any o2 sensors in our cats.....so no o2 hole is needed. Is there really a difference between a hi flow cat and a resonator? performance wise I mean
Offline

Taylor

naturalsk8ter17 wrote:
Is there really a difference between a hi flow cat and a resonator? performance wise I mean
A resonator is there to keep the noise down while the catalyitc converter is there to remove polutants from the exhaust flow. So to answer your question yes there is a difference.
Here is an article that you may find interesting...
Resonator
Catalytic Converter
Offline

Matt Pitt


like ive said before, high flow cats are retarded. its either gonna not flow very well like your stock cat or it will fail the sniffer test. if you are worried about it just leave your stock one.



Offline

Marc

The Pitt wrote:
like ive said before, high flow cats are retarded IMO. its either gonna not flow very well like your stock cat or it will fail the sniffer test. if you are worried about it just leave your stock one.
Fixed. I have gone from stock midpipe to straight pipe with hi flow cat and love it. The straight through setup lost a bit of power in the low end, and breathed better up top, but it was not worth the trade. With the cat in there, she feels better off the line and does not choke or anything up top. I have not done a sniffer test so I cannot attest to that. I still have a stock midsection with 15K on the cat, so I have the best of both worlds when it comes time to pass smog. IMHO of course.
/$.02
Last edited by Marcatarkon (2008-08-26 15:26:48)
Offline

Blake

Marcatarkon wrote:
The Pitt wrote:
like ive said before, high flow cats are retarded IMO. its either gonna not flow very well like your stock cat or it will fail the sniffer test. if you are worried about it just leave your stock one.
Fixed. I have gone from stock midpipe to straight pipe with hi flow cat and love it. The straight through setup lost a bit of power in the low end, and breathed better up top, but it was not worth the trade. With the cat in there, she feels better off the line and does not choke or anything up top. I have not done a sniffer test so I cannot attest to that. I still have a stock midsection with 15K on the cat, so I have the best of both worlds when it comes time to pass smog. IMHO of course.
/$.02
so you had a strait pipe and werent satisfied so you threw a hi flow cat in there to give you some low end?
Offline

Marc

naturalsk8ter17 wrote:
Marcatarkon wrote:
The Pitt wrote:
like ive said before, high flow cats are retarded IMO. its either gonna not flow very well like your stock cat or it will fail the sniffer test. if you are worried about it just leave your stock one.
Fixed. I have gone from stock midpipe to straight pipe with hi flow cat and love it. The straight through setup lost a bit of power in the low end, and breathed better up top, but it was not worth the trade. With the cat in there, she feels better off the line and does not choke or anything up top. I have not done a sniffer test so I cannot attest to that. I still have a stock midsection with 15K on the cat, so I have the best of both worlds when it comes time to pass smog. IMHO of course.
/$.02so you had a strait pipe and werent satisfied so you threw a hi flow cat in there to give you some low end?
Pretty much. The straight pipe was
a) way to loud for my taste
b) felt like I lost a little off the line oomph
c) was a poor design and always ended up giving me an exhaust leak where the Header met the midpipe.
So I put the stock midpipe back on there. I regained the bit of low end and it quieted it down 'some'.
My fix was to add the magnaflow AND a stock midpipe header side flange that I picked up used.
Now, it may not be 'true' 2.5" all the way through due to the stock flange, but it is the best I could come up with.
1) Good low end
2) Quiet sound
3) no choking up in the higher RPMs that I notice.
Last edited by Marcatarkon (2008-08-26 17:13:46)
Offline

I retract my original statement. The High-Flow cat that I had wasn't made my Magnaflow. Mine was made by Random Technology.
Offline

Jeff (Not MajorMods)

So what shape is the one the stock 07 has? I want to get the same one just to make sure there are no issues.
Or does it not matter the shape, as long as the piping is the right diameter?
oh, and just to be 100% sure, the stock piping is 2.25, right?
Last edited by whysoSERious (2008-08-26 20:08:56)
Offline

Jeff (Not MajorMods)

Any chance someone could answer? I tried looking it up myself and couldn't find anything, I'd like to try and order the part ASAP.
Offline

The shape shouldn't matter. I never paid attention to it when I looked under my car. I'll have to look under it the next time I go outside.
Offline

Marc

whysoSERious wrote:
So what shape is the one the stock 07 has? I want to get the same one just to make sure there are no issues.
Or does it not matter the shape, as long as the piping is the right diameter?
oh, and just to be 100% sure, the stock piping is 2.25, right?
The shape doesn't matter. The 'exhaust channel' under the car should be wide enough for an oval shape...
The stock diameter MAY be 2.25, but you lose a lot because I think they use crush bends... I'd wait to have someone confirm as I'm a B15 guy trying to answer a B16 question...
Offline

Jeff (Not MajorMods)

Well the round 2.25 is like $66 and the long oval 2.25 is 83. If the shape doesnt matter, i'd rather just get the cheaper one.
Offline

Jeff (Not MajorMods)

And i noticed they also come in different body length and overall lengths. Anyone know what size i should get to ensure that it will fit?
Offline

Jeff (Not MajorMods)

http://cgi.ebay.com/ebaymotors/MagnaFlo … 0281715748
This is the one i was looking at specifically.
Offline

Marc

That looks pretty similar to the one I added. I don't what the B16's look like underneath, but that 'should' fit on a B15 just fine.
Offline

Jeff (Not MajorMods)

anyone to comment for the b16 before i make purchase?
Offline

Blake

should be good
Last edited by naturalsk8ter17 (2008-08-28 15:36:35)
Offline

Jeff (Not MajorMods)

I ordered it today, I will let everyone know how the install goes once it is done.
Offline

Jeff (Not MajorMods)

so the cat came in today. I was curious though, is there a way to tell if it is really a high flow cat just by looking at it, or are all the magnaflow ones high flow?
The website I ordered it from says it was high flow, but the box doesnt say anything. I am going to call the muffler shop tomorrow to have it put on, so I'll post updates when it gets done.
Offline

Marc

whysoSERious wrote:
so the cat came in today. I was curious though, is there a way to tell if it is really a high flow cat just by looking at it, or are all the magnaflow ones high flow?
The website I ordered it from says it was high flow, but the box doesnt say anything. I am going to call the muffler shop tomorrow to have it put on, so I'll post updates when it gets done.
Same damn thing. The shop I went to had old boxes and new boxes. The new boxes were EXACTLY the same, but with a bit of tape over the 'HI' portion. Maybe the newest packaging have them removed all together. I asked the shop owner why and he just shrugged his shoulders. My best guess would be either marketing, liability, or some idiot suing them...
Offline

Jeff (Not MajorMods)

So I can't find an exhaust shop in my area that will install it, even though it is CARB, EPA, and OBDII certified. (I ordered a different one than in the links i showed.)
I'm just gonna return it, oh well.
Offline

Jason


wtf are you serious? what's their reasoning? don't tell them it's a high flow cat, if they're already this stupid they shouldn't ask. if they do ask, just say it's supposed to be lighter and there's been issues of the stock cat clogging and catching fire underneath. i know that's not true but they may not lol.
Offline

Jeff (Not MajorMods)

I used review sites to do my searching. I filtered out all the places that got horrible reviews, because I was looking for a good welder with a small brain. Unfortunately it seems all the smart ass people work right in my town of south san francisco. The first place i called went something like this.
"Hi, I'm looking to have my catalytic converter replaced"
(chinese woman) We don't do catawitic conwerters, bewwy illeeegal" *click*
Okay, fuck that place.
2nd place.
"Hi, I'm looking to have my catalytic converter replaced"
"What kind of a car is it?"
"2007 sentra se-r spec v"
"one moment"
"im sorry, the only catalytic converter available is the stock one. Even thought i supply magnaflow high flow converters that are carb legal, they do not list your car under the applications list, which makes it illegal for me to install it, sorry."
3rd place
(ill start this off from where he started talking)
"Yeah, what kind of car do you have?"
"2007 sentra se-r spec v"
"let me check my applications book to find out if the vehicle is applicable, and ill give you a call back"
"ok thanks" (in my head -> dont bother)
I already sent the cat back to be replaced, i'm just gonna pick up that tanabe concept g and ill be happy.
Last edited by whysoSERious (2008-09-09 14:21:09)
Offline

Gorilla Bear

wow cali sux


Offline